$189 Kindle 2 vs Nook 3G and Nook WiFi – Pros and Cons

With the introduction of the new Nook Wi-Fi and subsequent price-drops of the Nook 3G and Kindle 2, choosing the best device of the three can be a difficult decision.

So which one is the best ereader to choose?

Well, the good news is that you really can’t go wrong with any of them at these new price points, and choosing one just depends on a few different factors that you’ll need to consider. This article compares the $189 Kindle 2 International versus the $199 Nook 3G and $149 Nook Wi-Fi, so you can easily weigh the pros and cons of each to find out which one is best suited for your specific reading needs and wants.

The Pros and Cons are directly comparing Nook vs Kindle, meaning the pros for the Nook are features that the Kindle doesn’t have and vice versa. In considering the Nook Wi-Fi, it has all the same exact features as the original Nook, just without the 3G wireless.

Nook Pros

Nook WiFiBarnes & Noble Nook

  • Supports Adobe EPUB and PDF DRM, meaning ebooks can be purchased from many websites other than B&N.
  • Compatible with Overdrive.com for free ebooks through local libraries. How to »
  • Free 3G wireless connection to B&N’s online ebook store ($199 model).
  • Color LCD touchscreen pane for navigation, typing, etc.
  • Wi-Fi, plus free Wi-Fi at B&N stores and AT&T hotspots.
  • Web browser using Wi-Fi.
  • Adjustable font type.
  • Micro SD card slot.
  • In store ebook promotions for free ebooks.
  • User replaceable battery.
  • Lend a purchased ebook one time for 14 days (if approved by publisher).
  • Android operating system is hackable.

Nook Cons

  • Not available internationally.
  • Limited ebook organization options, no customizable folders.
  • Notes, highlighting not very functional.
  • Subtracting the free ebooks, B&N has 151,743.
  • No text-to-speech.
  • Poor PDF support.
  • Battery life is less because of color screen and Wi-Fi.
  • Heavier.
  • No landscape mode.
nook from barnes and noble

Kindle 2 Pros

Kindle 2Amazon Kindle 2

  • Basic web browser with free internet using free 3G.
  • Over 615,000 total ebooks available in the Kindle ebook store.
  • Now supports collections (folders) for organizing ebooks.
  • Almost 200 newspaper and magazine subscriptions available, compared to B&N’s 33.
  • Available to over 170 countries.
  • Free wireless in over 100 countries.
  • Several exclusive free ebooks added monthly.
  • 30-day return policy vs Nook’s 14.
  • Text-to-speech (if approved by publisher).
  • Compatible with audiobooks from Audible.com.
  • Keyboard more functional for typing and adding notes.

Kindle 2 Cons

  • Amazon’s proprietary ebook DRM.
  • Doesn’t support EPUB without conversion.
  • Not compatible with ebooks from libraries.
  • No memory card slots.
  • The Kindle Store has limited search options.
  • Less appealing aesthetically.
  • Doesn’t have Wi-Fi.

2 Responses to “$189 Kindle 2 vs Nook 3G and Nook WiFi – Pros and Cons”

  1. if you look at amazon.com, all of the models of the kindle 2 have wi-fi